In today's diverse lending landscape, small business owners have more financing options than ever before. While traditional banks have been the historical go-to source for business loans, alternative lenders have emerged to fill gaps in the market and serve businesses in new ways. Understanding the distinctions between these options can help you make an informed decision about which type of lender might best serve your needs.

Understanding Traditional Banks

Traditional banks, including national banks, regional banks, and community banks, have been the cornerstone of business lending for generations. Let's explore how they operate and what that means for borrowers.

How Traditional Banks Work

Traditional banks typically follow a highly structured lending process developed over many years of experience. They gather deposits from customers and then lend these funds out to borrowers, making their profit on the interest rate spread between what they pay depositors and what they charge borrowers.

These institutions operate under strict regulatory oversight, which influences their lending practices in several ways:

• They must maintain specific capital reserves
• They follow standardized underwriting procedures
• They require extensive documentation
• They must justify their lending decisions to regulators

Advantages of Traditional Banks

Traditional banks offer several significant benefits to borrowers:

Lower Interest Rates Because banks have access to customer deposits and can borrow at favorable rates from the Federal Reserve, they typically offer the lowest interest rates available, particularly for well-qualified borrowers.

Relationship Banking Banks often provide a full suite of financial services, allowing you to build a comprehensive banking relationship that might include:

• Checking and savings accounts
• Merchant services
• Treasury management
• Investment services
• Insurance products

Stability and Longevity Established banks offer:

• Long-term relationship potential
• Predictable lending practices
• Strong regulatory oversight
• FDIC insurance on deposits
• Established reputations

Multiple Product Options Traditional banks typically offer various lending products:

• Term loans
• Lines of credit
• Equipment financing
• Commercial mortgages
• SBA loans
• Trade financing

Challenges with Traditional Banks

However, traditional banks also present certain challenges:

Stringent Requirements Banks typically require:

• Strong credit scores (usually 680+)
• Several years in business
• Significant collateral
• Detailed financial documentation
• Proven cash flow

Longer Processing Times The traditional bank lending process often involves:

• Multiple levels of review
• Extensive documentation requirements
• Committee approvals
• Longer waiting periods for funds

Conservative Lending Practices Banks tend to be more conservative in their lending, which can mean:

• Lower approval rates
• Smaller loan amounts
• More restrictive covenants
• Less flexibility in troubled times

Understanding Alternative Lenders

Alternative lenders encompass a diverse group of non-bank lenders that have emerged to serve businesses through different lending models and technologies.

How Alternative Lenders Work

Alternative lenders typically operate with different business models than banks:

• They often use private capital rather than deposits
• They employ technology-driven underwriting
• They focus on specific types of lending
• They may operate entirely online

Advantages of Alternative Lenders

Alternative lenders offer several distinct advantages:

Faster Processing Through technology and streamlined processes, alternative lenders often provide:

• Quick online applications
• Rapid approval decisions
• Fast funding (sometimes within 24 hours)
• Minimal paperwork requirements

More Flexible Requirements Alternative lenders may approve loans based on:

• Shorter time in business
• Lower credit scores
• Alternative data points
• Less traditional collateral

Innovative Products Many alternative lenders offer specialized financing options:

• Revenue-based financing
• Merchant cash advances
• Invoice financing
• Equipment leasing
• Purchase order financing
• Inventory financing

Specialized Industry Focus Some alternative lenders focus on specific industries, offering:

• Industry-specific underwriting
• Specialized product features
• Better understanding of business cycles
• Tailored repayment terms

Challenges with Alternative Lenders

Alternative lending also comes with certain drawbacks:

Higher Costs Due to their business model and risk tolerance, alternative lenders typically charge:

• Higher interest rates
• Additional fees
• More frequent payments
• Higher overall cost of capital

Shorter Terms Alternative loans often feature:

• Shorter repayment periods
• More frequent payment requirements
• Less flexibility in payment timing
• Stricter default terms

Less Regulatory Oversight The alternative lending sector has:

• Fewer regulatory requirements
• Less standardized practices
• Varying levels of transparency
• Different consumer protections

Making Your Choice: Key Considerations

When deciding between traditional banks and alternative lenders, consider these factors:

Time Sensitivity

If you need funds quickly:

• Alternative lenders typically provide faster approval and funding
• Traditional banks require more time but offer better rates
• Consider whether the speed premium is worth the additional cost

Cost Sensitivity

When evaluating costs:

• Calculate the total cost of borrowing, not just the interest rate
• Consider the impact of payment frequency on cash flow
• Factor in fees and prepayment penalties
• Evaluate the cost relative to your expected return on investment

Qualification Factors

Assess your likelihood of approval:

• Review your credit score and history
• Calculate your time in business
• Evaluate your available collateral
• Consider your documentation readiness

Relationship Value

Think about your long-term banking needs:

• Consider the value of building a banking relationship
• Evaluate your need for additional financial services
• Think about future financing needs
• Assess the importance of face-to-face interaction

Purpose of Financing

Match the lender to your needs:

• Long-term assets typically fit better with traditional bank financing
• Short-term needs might be better served by alternative lenders
• Specialized financing needs might require specific lender expertise
• Consider whether the funding purpose aligns with the lender's focus

Hybrid Approaches

Sometimes the best solution involves using both traditional and alternative lenders:

Complementary Financing

Consider how different lenders might work together:

• Use bank financing for long-term needs
• Employ alternative lenders for short-term opportunities
• Maintain relationships with multiple funding sources
• Create a financing stack that matches your needs

Building Toward Bank Financing

If you're currently using alternative lenders:

• Work on improving your bank qualification factors
• Build your business credit history
• Maintain organized financial records
• Develop banking relationships even before you need them

Conclusion

Both traditional banks and alternative lenders play important roles in the business lending ecosystem. The best choice depends on your specific circumstances, including:

• Your immediate and long-term financing needs
• Your qualification profile
• Your timeline for funding
• Your cost sensitivity
• Your relationship preferences

Consider starting with a thorough evaluation of your business needs and qualifications, then explore options from both traditional banks and alternative lenders. Remember that your choice today doesn't lock you into a single path – many businesses successfully use different types of lenders as their needs and qualifications evolve.

Take time to understand the total cost of borrowing, not just the interest rate, and ensure you fully understand the terms and requirements of any financing you pursue. When in doubt, consider consulting with a financial advisor who can help you evaluate your options and make the choice that best serves your business goals.

‍